Between Scientists & Citizens

Posts Tagged ‘Pielke Principle

Morano Analysis #7: Scientific consensus

with 13 comments

This mini-debate between  Maslin and Morano first caught my attention because of Morano’s “accusation” that Maslin was using an “appeal to authority,” and Maslin’s assertion of something like a scientific consensus in reply. Claims that the IPCC represents an authoritative “consensus” have been prominent in representations of the IPCC’s reports since the very beginning, and in one of my current projects I’m trying to figure out how consensus claims  work (or don’t).  The example here, though small, is worth examining closely.

Read the rest of this entry »

Written by jeangoodwin

March 17, 2010 at 12:38 pm