Between Scientists & Citizens

Posts Tagged ‘Pielke

Making arguments expensive

with 41 comments

Back in the golden age of the climate controversy–say, about 18 months ago–there was a time when everybody was challenging everybody else to debate. I suppose you couldn’t click more than a few links before tripping over a gauntlet.

What does a formal debate offer that the ordinary disorderly flow of arguing in the blogosphere doesn’t?  To pick up on a theme from my last post:  a formal debate allows the participants to control  what they are taking responsibility for–and to force others to take responsibility, too.  Roger Pielke, Jr. is a masterful debater, and his recent challenge to critics of “climate pragmatism” shows this strategy at its finest.

Read the rest of this entry »

Written by jeangoodwin

August 2, 2011 at 9:50 pm

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.